How the Criminalization of Poverty Perpetuates Homelessness
How the Criminalization of Poverty Perpetuates Homelessness
A growing literature examines the extent to which the criminal justice system perpetuates poverty and inequality. Studies reveal the mechanisms through which consistent punitive interactions, including move-along orders, citations, and destruction of property, systematically limit homeless people’s access to services, housing, and jobs, while damaging their health, safety, and well-being. It is arguable that these laws and their enforcements constitute a larger process of pervasive penalty—consistent punitive interactions with state officials that rarely result in arrest, but that do material and psychological harm. This process not only reproduces homelessness, but also deepens racial, gender, and health inequalities among the urban poor (Herring, Yarbrough, Alatorre).
A Growing Homeless Population is Now in the Spotlight
Nearly 50 million Americans now live below the federal poverty line. Recent societal, economic, and political events have generated unprecedented public awareness of historic levels of income inequality, children in poverty, and disparate treatment and impacts of the law and justice systems on communities of color and populations that face other barriers and obstacles to justice (ABA).
Lack of Alternative Placement for those Facing Homelessness
Every day in America, people experiencing homelessness are threatened by law enforcement, ticketed, or even arrested for living in public spaces, even when they have no other alternatives. Millions of individuals, families, and youth on their own experience homelessness each year, and millions more lack access to decent, stable housing they can afford. Rather than providing adequate housing options, too many communities criminalize homelessness by making it illegal for people to sit, sleep, or even eat in public places, despite the absence of adequate alternatives (NLIHC).
Substandard and Unaffordable Housing Lead to Homelessness
Even where needy applicants are able to obtain housing assistance or access affordable housing, they often face discrimination in the private housing market on the basis of race, disability, gender, sexual orientation, source of income, criminal background, or other status. More work needs to be done to ensure equal access to housing resources. This includes ensuring availability of various types of home and community based support services that enable individuals and families to live independently as long as possible. Additionally, as was seen following Hurricanes Katrina and Sandy, many traditionally marginalized groups feel a disparate impact during natural disasters, and the right to adequate housing must be ensured appropriately in the post-disaster context as well (ABA).
Criminalizing Poverty with No Solution Merely Perpetuates the Problem
By issuing tickets or fines, or actually arresting an individual solves nothing for the homeless population. If a homeless person is given a ticket and move along orders, they simply carry that debt with them, and the community has wasted law enforcement's time and resources to issue a ticket that will likely never be collected. If they are arrested, that get's them off the street for a couple of hours or days, but does nothing to improve their outcome when released back onto the street. Again, this is a waste of time and resources.
Stigma and Lack of Personal Dignity
Generally, there is a misunderstanding by the public about who is poor or homeless and the causes of poverty and homelessness. This creates a stigma that negatively impacts the poor and homeless. Roughly half of Americans (51%) believe “lack of will” is one cause of poverty. Several studies have shown that Americans tend to attribute poverty and homelessness to individuals’ shortcomings (ABA).
General Health and Wellbeing
Homeless people often encounter a lot of health issues in their lives. Their health gets worse from time to time because they lack attention from people such as doctors, wives, husbands, and family members. And because of lack of necessities they suffer from multiple diseases such as (UCLA/WSU):
Physical and sexual assault
Homelessness is a growing problem that negatively impacts the nation’s economic competitiveness.
Burden on the Public Healthcare Systems
The unsheltered homeless population also has an increased risk of exposure to communicable diseases (ASP). This places an extra strain on an already vulnerable community who depend on free public health care.
Wasted Law Enforcement Resources
According to the administrative officer for the city of Los Angeles in a 2015 report, although only four agencies and departments had budgetary allocations for homeless programs, at least 15 regularly engaged with homeless people, with some departments incurring large costs. For example, the report cited that the Los Angeles Police Department estimated it spent from $53.6 million to $87.3 million in one year on interactions with homeless people and the Bureau of Sanitation spent at least $547,000 in a year on cleanup of homeless encampments (ASP).
Create more safe places for homeless people that have resources on health, addiction, housing and employment
Reduce homelessness by growing the economy and bolstering public education.
Public Health Systems
Law Enforcement Agencies
StreetChange is a mobile application that leverages the power of small donations to help people that need it the most: homeless neighbors with short-term needs. Through iOS and Android apps you can contribute to necessities like socks, shoes, and raincoats requested by StreetChange clients who meet with a caseworker to discuss healthcare and housing options when picking up their goods.
Implement Homeless Courts
To counter the effect of criminal cases pushing homeless defendants further outside society, homeless courts across the country combine a progressive plea bargain system, alternative sentencing structure, assurance of “no custody,” and proof of program activities to address a full range of misdemeanor offenses.
Alternative sentencing activities take the place of agency program participation for fines and custody; they include life-skills, chemical dependency or AA/NA meetings, computer or English literacy classes, training or search for employment, counseling and education (ABA).
Create More Resources for and Introduce the Homeless Population to Existing Resources
Shelter App, Inc. is an All-volunteer Non-Profit Organization whose mission is to help homeless and low-income families connect to services using the web and mobile app where they can find Food, Shelter, Health, Work and other resources.
People experiencing homelessness rely on the internet to apply for housing and benefits, schedule appointments with doctors and case managers, search for jobs, and stay in touch with family and friends. It is a lifeline for getting back on your feet. ShelterConnect works with internet service providers to offer free wifi in shelters and transitional housing facilities.
Samaritan can enable cities or large employers to mobilize their members and engage with the single mom on the bus, the grandfather on the street, or the homeless teen outside the supermarket. When you cross paths with a Samaritan Beacon Holder, a notification will appear on your phone. Tapping on the notification provides an opportunity to engage and be of help.
Pervasive Penality: How the Criminalization of Poverty Perpetuates Homelessness- https://academic.oup.com/socpro/article-abstract/67/1/131/5422958
The Impact of Homelessness on Economic Competitiveness- https://www.americansecurityproject.org/impact-homelessness-economic-competitiveness/
How you can Help End Homelessness-https://depts.washington.edu/triolive/quest/2007/TTQ07033/solutions.html
Criminalization of Homelessness-https://nlihc.org/sites/default/files/AG-2019/06-08_Criminalization-of-Homelessness.pdf
Combatting Poverty and Decriminalizing Homelessness Through a Race Equity Lens-https://www.americanbar.org/groups/public_interest/homelessness_poverty/race-equity-decriminalization-homelessness/
Giving Tech Labs team - giving.tech